Look, I’ll be honest with you – when someone first told me they got a room at the Sheraton Tribeca for under $150 a night, I called BS. This is New York we’re talking about. Tribeca, specifically. The neighborhood where you can barely buy a sandwich for under fifteen bucks, let me tell you.

But here I am, three trips to NYC later, and I’ve stayed at this exact hotel twice for prices that would make most travel booking sites weep. The first time was almost by accident (more on that disaster-turned-victory in a minute), and the second time I knew exactly what I was doing. And honestly? Learning how to book expensive hotels for cheap has completely changed how I travel to pricey cities.

So let me walk you through exactly how I did it, what worked, what flopped, and how you can book the Sheraton Tribeca – or pretty much any hotel in New York – without selling a kidney.

The Time I Accidentally Hacked My Way Into a Deal

This whole thing started because I screwed up. Seriously. I’d booked what I thought was a hostel in Brooklyn for a work trip to New York back in 2019, only to realize three days before my flight that I’d actually booked it for the wrong month. Yeah. That happened.

I was scrambling, refreshing every hotel site I could find, watching prices that made my checking account nervous. Everything in Manhattan was sitting at $300+ per night, and I only had four nights to cover. Then I remembered something a friend had mentioned at a travel meetup – hotel auction sites.

I’d never used one before, but desperate times, right? I hopped onto Priceline’s “Express Deals” at like 11 PM, saw a 4-star hotel in Tribeca listed for $142 a night, and just… went for it. Didn’t even know which hotel it was until after I paid. Turned out to be the Sheraton Tribeca, and when I looked up the regular rate? It was going for $380 that same night on their website.

I felt like I’d won the lottery, honestly. And that’s when I started actually paying attention to how hotel pricing works in New York.

Understanding the Weird World of NYC Hotel Pricing

Here’s the thing about booking hotels in New York – the prices are absolutely bananas and they change constantly. Like, more than airline prices, which is saying something. I’ve seen the same room at the Sheraton Tribeca fluctuate by $200 in a single day.

The secret that most people don’t realize is that hotels would rather have a room occupied at a lower rate than have it sit empty. This is especially true for business hotels like the Sheraton Tribeca, which sees a ton of corporate travelers during the week but can get quiet on weekends. I learned this the hard way when I tried to book a Tuesday night once (business travel night) and nearly cried at the prices, versus a Saturday when rates dropped by almost 40%.

Tribeca itself is kind of an interesting neighborhood for deals, too. It’s not Times Square, so it doesn’t have that crazy tourist surcharge built in, but it’s also not far from anything. When I stayed there, I was a 15-minute walk from the World Trade Center and could get pretty much anywhere in Manhattan without much hassle.

The Booking Strategies That Actually Work

So after that first accidental win, I got kind of obsessed with figuring out the formula. I’ve now booked the Sheraton Tribeca twice more (and several other NYC hotels) using these exact strategies, and I’m going to break down what consistently works.

First up: timing is everything. I know everyone says this, but trust me, it matters even more in New York. The sweet spot I’ve found is booking about 3-4 weeks out for the best rates. Too far in advance and you’re paying the rack rate. Too close and you’re competing with desperate business travelers with expense accounts. Those Express Deals and opaque bookings through Priceline or Hotwire? They get better as the date approaches, but it’s a gamble because rooms can sell out.

I also learned to be flexible with my dates if at all possible. Checking in on a Sunday or Thursday instead of Friday? You’ll save money. Staying through a Tuesday? Even better. The Sheraton Tribeca, like most business hotels, is way cheaper on weekends. My best rate there was actually for a Saturday night – I paid $128 when the regular rate was sitting at $340. The room was exactly the same as when I paid more on a Thursday.

The loyalty program thing is real, too. I signed up for Marriott Bonvoy (Sheraton is part of Marriott) after my first stay, and even though I’m definitely not elite status or anything fancy, I do get member-only rates sometimes. It’s free to join and occasionally knocks off another $20-30. Not life-changing, but it adds up.

The Booking Sites You Need to Check

Okay, so this is where I’m going to sound like I’m all over the place, but hear me out. I literally check seven different sites before booking any NYC hotel now. It sounds excessive, and my boyfriend definitely thinks I’m crazy, but we’re talking about potentially saving $100+ per night.

Start with the hotel’s actual website. I know, I know – it seems counterintuitive. But sometimes they have deals that booking sites don’t advertise, especially if you’re a Bonvoy member. The Sheraton Tribeca website occasionally has package deals or “advance purchase” rates that are legitimately competitive.

Then hit up the usual suspects: Booking.com, Hotels.com, Expedia. These are pretty straightforward and sometimes have “secret deals” or loyalty rewards. Hotels.com does that thing where you get a free night after ten stays, which I’ve actually used twice now for other trips.

But here’s where it gets interesting: Priceline Express Deals and Hotwire. These are the opaque bookings where you don’t know exactly which hotel you’re getting until after you pay. Sounds sketchy, but the discounts are real. You’ll see “4-star hotel in Tribeca” and that narrows it down to basically three options, one of which is usually the Sheraton. The savings can be massive – we’re talking 30-50% off sometimes.

I also check Costco Travel if you have a membership (it’s worth it for travel alone, honestly). They sometimes have hotel packages that include breakfast or parking, which can be clutch in NYC where breakfast at a hotel restaurant can easily run $25.

Last resort: apps like HotelTonight or LastMinute.com. I used HotelTonight once when I needed a place the same day, and while it wasn’t the cheapest I’ve ever paid, it was still $100 less than booking direct would have been.

The Credit Card Hack I Wish I’d Known Earlier

This is going to sound like I’m shilling for credit cards, but I’m not getting paid to say this – I just wish someone had told me about this years ago. Travel credit cards with hotel points are absurdly good value for NYC hotels.

I got the Marriott Bonvoy credit card specifically for my third NYC trip, and after the signup bonus (which was like 75,000 points at the time), I had enough for two free nights at the Sheraton Tribeca. Free. The annual fee was $95, but those rooms would have cost me at least $500 total. The math was stupid easy.

Even if you don’t want to go the points route, a lot of travel cards give you credits for hotel bookings or have portals where you can book at a discount. My Chase Sapphire card (the regular one, not the fancy Reserve) lets me book through their portal and my points are worth 25% more for travel. It’s honestly transformed how I book hotels.

Just be smart about it – don’t carry a balance or rack up debt for travel points. That’s how you turn a good deal into a terrible financial decision really fast.

What to Know Before You Actually Book the Sheraton Tribeca

Real talk: the Sheraton Tribeca is a solid hotel, but it’s not perfect. The rooms are nice – I mean, they’re standard hotel rooms, nothing to write home about, but clean and comfortable. The beds were actually pretty great, which matters when you’re walking 20,000 steps a day exploring the city.

The location is genuinely good. You’re in Tribeca, which is quieter than Midtown but still super accessible. Canal Street station is like a five-minute walk, and you can catch multiple subway lines from there. I walked to the 9/11 Memorial in about fifteen minutes, and SoHo is right there too.

Here’s what’s not great: breakfast is expensive if you don’t have it included in your rate. We’re talking $30+ for a buffet. The first time I stayed there I made that mistake once and never again. There’s a great bagel place two blocks away that costs like $6 and is ten times better.

Also, parking. Don’t even think about it unless someone else is paying. It’s something like $60 a day, which is just absurd. If you’re driving to New York (which I don’t recommend), park in Jersey and take the train in.

The hotel does have a decent gym if that matters to you, and the lobby area is actually pretty nice to work from if you’re a digital nomad type like me. They’ve got good wifi and plenty of seating.

The Mistakes I Made So You Don’t Have To

Let me tell you about the time I tried to be too clever and it backfired. I saw an amazing rate on Priceline for a “mystery hotel” in Lower Manhattan – even cheaper than my usual Tribeca deals. I was so sure it would be the Sheraton or something comparable. It was not. I ended up in a hotel near the Financial District that had clearly seen better days, like maybe in 1987.

The lesson? Don’t chase the absolute rock-bottom price without checking reviews. Sometimes those crazy-low rates are low for a reason. The Sheraton Tribeca might not be the cheapest option you’ll find, but it’s reliably good, and that matters when you’re trying to enjoy your trip rather than deal with sketchy accommodations.

I also learned not to automatically dismiss the prepaid, non-refundable rates. I used to avoid them because I liked having flexibility, but honestly, if you’re sure about your dates, the savings can be substantial. I saved $45 per night once by going with the non-refundable option, and my trip went exactly as planned.

One more thing: don’t forget about taxes and fees. New York has some of the highest hotel taxes in the country – we’re talking 14.75% plus an occupancy tax. That $150 rate you see? It’s actually going to be closer to $180 after everything. Always factor that in when comparing options.

Making It Work for Your Trip

Look, booking hotels in New York is never going to be as cheap as booking a guesthouse in Thailand or whatever. But getting a legit hotel like the Sheraton Tribeca for $130-160 a night instead of $300+? That’s the difference between being able to afford the trip or not for a lot of people.

My advice is to start looking early but don’t book immediately. Set up price alerts on Google Hotels or Hotwire so you can watch how rates fluctuate for your dates. I’ve found that prices for the Sheraton Tribeca tend to drop about 2-3 weeks before check-in, especially for weekend stays.

Be ready to pounce when you see a good deal. I keep my credit card info saved on my most-used booking sites because I’ve literally lost deals while fumbling for my wallet. It sounds paranoid, but when a $140 rate can jump to $240 in an hour, speed matters.

And honestly? Sometimes it’s worth paying a bit more for the right location. The money you save on transportation by being centrally located in Tribeca versus staying in like, Queens or deep Brooklyn, can offset a slightly higher hotel rate. Plus, your vacation time is valuable. I learned this the hard way after staying in an outer borough once to save $40 a night and spending an hour each way on the subway.

The Sheraton Tribeca has been my go-to NYC hotel for good reason. It’s not the cheapest option in the city, but when you can get it for 50-60% off using these strategies, it’s hands-down the best value I’ve found. And after staying there multiple times, I know exactly what I’m getting, which gives me peace of mind when I’m planning a trip.

So there you have it – everything I’ve learned about booking this specific hotel without breaking the bank. Will you get a $100 rate every time? Probably not. But somewhere in the $130-180 range is totally doable if you’re strategic about it, and that’s legitimately impressive for a nice hotel in one of the most expensive cities in the world.

Now go forth and book that New York trip. Trust me, it’s worth it.

---