---

So here’s the thing about staying near Madison Square Garden in New York – everyone tells you it’s going to cost an arm and a leg, and honestly, they’re not entirely wrong. But I’ve crashed in this neighborhood more times than I can count (concerts, Knicks games, that one time I had a layover that turned into an impromptu 48-hour NYC adventure), and I’ve figured out some tricks that won’t leave your wallet crying.

Last spring, I paid $89 a night for a hotel literally three blocks from MSG. My friend Sarah thought I was making it up until I showed her the receipt. The secret isn’t some magic booking site or knowing a guy who knows a guy – it’s about understanding how New York hotel pricing actually works and being a bit flexible with your expectations.

Why Location Matters More Than You Think (But Maybe Not How You Think)

Look, I get the appeal of staying right next to Madison Square Garden. You’re probably going to a Rangers game, catching a concert, or maybe you’ve got business in Midtown and don’t want to deal with the subway at midnight. I’ve been there. The first time I visited NYC for a Billy Joel concert back in 2019, I stayed in Brooklyn to save money and spent almost as much on Ubers because I was terrified of the subway at night. Not my smartest move.

But here’s what I’ve learned: “near” Madison Square Garden is a pretty flexible concept in Manhattan. The Garden is right at Penn Station, which means you’ve got excellent subway access. A hotel that’s technically in Chelsea or Midtown West might be a seven-minute walk instead of three, but you could save $60-100 per night. That’s money you can spend on actually enjoying the city instead of just looking at it from your hotel window.

The neighborhoods immediately around MSG – we’re talking the area between 28th and 42nd Streets, roughly from 6th to 9th Avenue – tend to have the most options. You’re not going to find many “charming boutique” places here. This is functional New York, the part of the city that’s all business until the sun goes down and the theaters light up.

The Hotels I Actually Recommend (Because I’ve Slept in Them)

Let me be real with you – I’m not going to pretend these are luxurious. But they’re clean, safe, and they won’t destroy your budget. I’ve stayed in some version of these hotels probably six or seven times over the years.

The Hotel Pennsylvania used to be my go-to recommendation, but it closed permanently in 2023 (RIP to those $99 rates). Since then, I’ve had good experiences with a few other spots. The Row NYC, right on 8th Avenue at 44th Street, is about a 10-minute walk to MSG. I stayed there in January 2024 and paid $115 a night during the week. The rooms are tiny – like, you have to shimmy between the bed and the wall – but it’s right in the Theater District and the location is unbeatable.

If you’re willing to go slightly further, Pod 51 has been my secret weapon. It’s technically in Midtown East, so it’s about a 20-minute walk or a quick subway ride to the Garden. The “pods” are legitimately small (we’re talking 75-100 square feet), but I’ve paid as little as $79 there. The rooftop bar is actually pretty decent, and the neighborhood feels safer and less chaotic than right around Penn Station.

The Hampton Inn Manhattan/Times Square Central kind of surprised me. I expected corporate blandness, and yeah, it delivered on that, but it was also consistently clean and the breakfast saved me probably $50 over a four-day stay. They run decent rates during off-season – I got it for $129 a night in February, which for Times Square location is pretty solid.

Timing Your Booking Like Your Bank Account Depends On It (Because It Does)

This is where I see people mess up constantly. They book too early or too late, and either way, they’re overpaying. New York hotel pricing is weird and kind of beautiful once you understand the pattern.

I generally start monitoring prices about 90-120 days before my trip. I’m not booking yet – I’m just watching. I use Google Hotels to track prices and set up alerts. Here’s what I’ve noticed: prices tend to drop about 3-6 weeks before arrival for weekdays, and about 2-3 weeks out for weekends. Unless there’s a massive event at MSG, in which case all bets are off and you should book the second you know your dates.

Last November, I watched a room at the New Yorker Hotel bounce from $189 to $129 to $167 back down to $119 over the course of six weeks. I grabbed it at $119, and honestly, I could’ve waited another week and probably gotten it for $109, but I didn’t want to risk it. This isn’t an exact science, and sometimes you just have to pull the trigger.

One thing I learned the hard way: booking a non-refundable rate to save $20 seems smart until your plans change. And in New York, plans change constantly. I now exclusively book refundable rates unless the non-refundable option is saving me at least $40-50 per night. Trust me on this – I’ve lost too much money on non-refundable bookings that I couldn’t use.

The Neighborhoods Nobody Talks About (But You Should Consider)

Okay, so technically these aren’t “close” to Madison Square Garden if we’re being literal about it, but hear me out. Chelsea, specifically the area around 23rd Street, is a 15-20 minute walk to MSG and feels way more like an actual neighborhood than the chaos around Penn Station. I stayed at a random Holiday Inn Express there in 2023 and paid $98 a night. The streets are quieter, there are actual restaurants instead of just tourist traps, and you’re still super accessible to the Garden.

Hell’s Kitchen – or as locals who actually live there call it, Midtown West – is another spot I recommend. It’s gotten way nicer over the past decade, and you’re still only 10-15 minutes from MSG. The Restaurant Row area has some surprisingly affordable places to eat, which matters when you’re trying to stick to a budget. I found a family-run Italian place there that did massive pasta portions for $14, and that fed me dinner and lunch the next day.

Murray Hill is slightly further east but don’t write it off. It’s more residential, which means it feels safer late at night when you’re walking back from a concert. The trade-off is that you’ll probably take the subway or a quick Uber to get to the Garden, but you’re saving $30-60 per night on accommodation, so the math works out.

What You’re Actually Getting For Your Money

Let’s set some realistic expectations here because I think that’s where people get disappointed and leave angry reviews. A $120 hotel room in Manhattan near Madison Square Garden is not the same as a $120 room in, say, Denver or Austin. You’re paying for location, and you need to adjust your expectations accordingly.

Your room will probably be small. Like really small. I’m talking 150-200 square feet in many cases. You’ll have a bed, a TV, maybe a small desk, and a bathroom. That’s it. There won’t be room for your suitcase AND your backpack to both be open at the same time. You’ll be doing the hotel shuffle, where you move things around just to navigate the space.

The view will probably be either a wall or an airshaft. I’ve stayed in so many NYC hotels where the “window” looks out at a brick wall five feet away. It’s just part of the deal. Bring an eye mask and earplugs because natural light and silence are luxuries that cost an extra $100 per night in this city.

But here’s what you SHOULD expect: cleanliness, functioning amenities, a decent bed, and a safe location. If the hotel can’t deliver on those basics, it doesn’t matter how cheap it is – find somewhere else. I’ve walked out of exactly one hotel in New York (won’t name it, but it was near the Javits Center) because the room smelled like mildew and the bathroom looked like it hadn’t been cleaned since the 90s. Being budget-conscious doesn’t mean accepting actual health hazards.

The Tricks Nobody Tells First-Time NYC Visitors

Here’s some stuff I wish someone had told me before my first trip to New York: booking directly with the hotel can sometimes be cheaper than third-party sites, especially if you call and ask about AAA discounts, government rates, or corporate codes. I’m not even kidding – just asking “do you have any discount codes available?” has saved me money more times than I can count.

Also, check if your credit card offers any hotel benefits. Some cards give you automatic status or discounts at certain chains. My Chase Sapphire Reserve (which I only got because the travel benefits actually pay for the annual fee) gets me late checkout and sometimes room upgrades at certain hotels. It’s not guaranteed, but it’s worth checking.

Skip the hotel breakfast unless it’s included. That $25 hotel buffet is a scam when you can walk two blocks and get a bacon egg and cheese from a bodega for $6. The exception is if you’re staying somewhere that includes breakfast in the rate – then definitely take advantage because eating out for every meal in Manhattan will wreck your budget fast.

Finally, don’t book a hotel with daily resort fees or mandatory facility charges unless you’ve factored that into the price. Some places advertise $109 rates but then hit you with a $35 daily “urban fee” or whatever they’re calling it these days. I always check the total price including all fees before I book.

Making It Work For Your Actual Trip

Look, I’m not going to pretend that finding cheap hotels near Madison Square Garden is easy. New York is expensive, and Midtown Manhattan is one of the priciest neighborhoods in one of the most expensive cities in the world. But it’s not impossible to do it on a budget if you’re strategic.

My general rule is this: if you’re paying more than $150 per night for a basic hotel room within walking distance of MSG, you’re probably overpaying unless it’s peak season or there’s a huge event happening. Use that as your benchmark. If prices are hovering around $180-200, consider staying a bit further out or shifting your dates if possible.

And honestly? Sometimes it makes more sense to stay in Brooklyn or Queens and take the subway in. I’ve done that plenty of times when Manhattan prices are just absurd. The commute adds 20-30 minutes, but if you’re saving $60-80 per night and you’re not staggering back to your hotel at 2 AM, it’s worth considering.

The most important thing is to book something that fits your actual needs and budget, not what some influencer on Instagram says is the “must-stay” spot. You’re going to spend most of your time out exploring the city anyway. Your hotel is basically just a place to sleep and shower.

Start monitoring prices early, be flexible when you can, and don’t be afraid to book something that’s a 15-minute walk instead of a 5-minute walk. Your wallet will thank you, and you’ll have more money to spend on the stuff that actually matters – like tickets to see your team play or that ridiculously expensive but totally worth it pizza from Prince Street Pizza.

---