So here’s the thing about the LA to New York route—I’ve flown it so many times at this point that I’m pretty sure the flight attendants recognize me. Okay, maybe not literally, but between visiting my sister in Brooklyn, attending blogging conferences, and chasing down cheap flight deals to Europe that require positioning from JFK, this has become my most-traveled route by a long shot.

And honestly? I’ve learned a ton about making this cross-country trek both affordable and bearable. Because let me tell you, there’s a huge difference between paying $600 for a cramped middle seat and snagging a $127 direct flight with actual legroom. I’ve experienced both ends of that spectrum, sometimes on the same trip (don’t ask).

The Basic Lay of the Land: Your NYC Airport Options

When you’re flying from LAX to New York, you’ve got three airports to choose from on the East Coast side: JFK, LaGuardia, and Newark. I know, technically Newark is in New Jersey, but it counts as a New York-area airport and honestly, depending on where you’re headed in the city, it might actually be your best bet.

JFK is the big international hub, and it’s what I usually aim for because the flight options are endless. You’ve got basically every major carrier running this route multiple times a day. I’m talking American, Delta, United, JetBlue, Alaska—the whole crew. LaGuardia is smaller and closer to Manhattan, which sounds great until you realize the airport itself is kind of a nightmare to navigate. Though I will say, they’ve done major renovations recently that have helped. Newark gets a bad rap, but the AirTrain connection to Manhattan is actually pretty smooth, and flights there tend to be slightly cheaper.

The flight time is consistently around 5 to 5.5 hours going eastbound. Coming back to LA takes about 6 hours because of headwinds, but that’s a story for another article. What matters is that you can leave LA in the morning and be eating a bagel in Manhattan by dinner time, which honestly never stops feeling kind of magical to me.

When I Book and Why It Matters More Than You Think

Here’s something I wish someone had told me before my first trip: the day and time you fly can literally change your ticket price by $300 or more. I learned this the hard way when I booked a Friday afternoon flight for $487, only to realize that if I’d left Tuesday morning instead, the same route was $164.

Tuesday, Wednesday, and Saturday flights tend to be your cheapest options. Everyone wants to fly out Friday evening or Monday morning for weekend trips, so airlines charge accordingly. I try to build my trips around those cheaper days now. Sure, it means sometimes I’m flying out super early or arriving late, but I’ve used the money I saved to fund entire weekend trips to other places.

The time of year matters too, obviously. I once made the mistake of trying to book a flight the week before Thanksgiving. The cheapest option was $521 one way. One way! I ended up pushing my trip back two weeks and paid $178 instead. Summer is pricey too, especially June through August. But here’s a weird quirk I’ve noticed: late January and February can be absolute goldmines for deals. I guess everyone’s broke from the holidays and not thinking about travel yet.

I typically book about 6-8 weeks in advance for the best prices. Any earlier and you’re not seeing the sales yet. Any later and you’re competing with everyone else for the remaining seats. Though I’ll admit, I’ve also scored some insane last-minute deals when airlines are trying to fill empty seats three days before departure. That’s more of a gamble though—works great if you’re flexible, absolute disaster if you have a specific date you need to travel.

The Airlines I Actually Choose (And the Ones I Avoid)

JetBlue is my go-to for this route, hands down. Free WiFi, decent legroom, and their prices are usually competitive. Plus, they fly into JFK Terminal 5, which is legitimately the nicest terminal I’ve ever experienced at that airport. I’m not getting paid to say that—I just really appreciate having food options that aren’t sad pizza and a Starbucks.

I flew them last March for $198 roundtrip and had an actual pleasant experience, which is saying something for domestic economy. The seat had enough room that my knees weren’t jammed into the seat in front of me, and I could work on my laptop without doing some weird contortionist routine. Small things, but they matter when you’re in a metal tube for five and a half hours.

Delta is my second choice, especially if you’re collecting SkyMiles or have status. They’re usually more expensive—we’re talking $40-80 more per ticket on average—but the reliability is solid. I’ve had fewer delays and cancellations with Delta than any other carrier on this route. When I absolutely cannot miss a connection or meeting, I’ll pay the extra for that peace of mind.

United and American are fine. They’re airlines, they get you there. I don’t have strong feelings either way, though American’s basic economy situation is pretty restrictive. You can’t even choose your seat or bring a full-size carry-on, which feels a bit much for a five-hour flight. I accidentally booked basic economy once without realizing it and ended up in a middle seat between two very large gentlemen who were apparently training for a snoring competition. Not my best travel day.

Alaska Airlines has been increasingly competitive on this route, especially if you’re going to Newark. I flew them last fall for $142 one way and was genuinely impressed. Good service, on-time departure, and their credit card actually has some decent perks if you fly with them regularly.

My Actual Strategy for Finding Cheap Flights

Okay, here’s what I actually do when I need to book this route, and trust me, this system has saved me literally thousands of dollars over the years.

First, I never, ever search for flights without using incognito mode or clearing my cookies. Airlines do track your searches, and prices can increase if they think you’re desperate to book. I learned this the paranoid way—I thought I was going crazy watching prices jump $60 overnight, but it turns out it was just dynamic pricing screwing with me.

I use Google Flights as my starting point because the calendar view shows you prices across an entire month. This is huge. You can literally see that flying on Tuesday the 14th is $189, but Friday the 17th is $356. Sometimes shifting your trip by just a day or two saves you enough to cover your accommodation.

I also have Going (formerly Scott’s Cheap Flights) alerts set up for LAX to NYC. They’ve caught some absolute steals for me, including a $127 roundtrip fare last January that I still can’t quite believe was real. You do have to be flexible with your dates to take advantage of these deals, but if you can make it work, it’s so worth it.

Here’s a weird trick that’s worked for me a few times: sometimes booking two one-way tickets is cheaper than a roundtrip. I don’t know why, airline pricing is basically black magic, but I always check both options. Just last month I saved $73 by booking my outbound on JetBlue and my return on Alaska instead of buying a roundtrip ticket from either airline.

If you’re not in a rush, set price alerts and wait. I’ve watched fares for this route drop by $150-200 during sales, which happen pretty regularly. Airlines usually announce sales on Tuesday afternoons, so that’s when I check most obsessively.

The Little Things That Actually Make the Flight Better

Look, I’m not going to pretend that any domestic economy flight is luxurious. It’s not. But there are things you can do to make those five-plus hours significantly less miserable.

Window seats on the left side of the plane give you the best views if you’re flying during daylight. You’ll see the Grand Canyon, parts of the Rockies, and if it’s clear, some amazing views as you approach New York. I’m kind of a nerd about this stuff, but honestly, it never gets old. I once sat next to a guy who’d never seen the Grand Canyon, even from the air, and watching his reaction made my middle seat situation totally worth it.

Bring real food. Trust me on this. Airport food is expensive and mediocre, and unless you’re flying JetBlue or Alaska, you’re not getting much more than a tiny bag of pretzels on the plane. I usually grab a sandwich and some snacks before boarding. My go-to is the turkey and avocado from Lemonade in Terminal 5 at LAX—it’s actually good and big enough that I have lunch and an afternoon snack sorted.

Download stuff before you board. Even though most airlines have WiFi now, it’s often spotty and sometimes expensive. I load up on podcasts, Netflix downloads, and work stuff while I’m still in the airport. Last time I forgot to do this, I spent five hours staring at the back of a seat because the WiFi wasn’t working and I’d finished the one magazine I brought within the first hour.

Noise-canceling headphones are worth every penny. I resisted buying them for years because they seemed like an unnecessary luxury, but they’re probably the best travel purchase I’ve ever made. Crying babies, chatty neighbors, engine noise—they all just fade away. I use mine on basically every flight now.

What Nobody Tells You About This Route

The weather can really mess with your plans. I’ve been delayed or rerouted because of winter storms on the East Coast more times than I can count. If you’re flying between December and March, build in some buffer time. I once missed an entire day of a conference because my morning flight got canceled due to snow in New York, and the next available seat wasn’t until the following morning.

Security lines at LAX are wildly unpredictable. I’ve breezed through in 15 minutes and I’ve also waited 90 minutes in the same terminal on different days. I always aim to get there two hours early for this reason, even though it sometimes means I’m just sitting at the gate for a while. Better bored than stressed and sprinting.

The time change is real. Three hours doesn’t sound like much, but when you land at 11 PM New York time and your body is convinced it’s only 8 PM, it can throw off your whole first day. I try to fly earlier in the day now so I can adjust to East Coast time before bed. Doesn’t always work out schedule-wise, but when it does, it makes a real difference.

Newark Airport requires a quick train ride to get to the terminals if you’re parking in the economy lot or getting dropped off. It’s not a huge deal, but factor in an extra 10-15 minutes that you wouldn’t need at LAX or most other airports.

Actually Making This Trip Work for Your Budget

Here’s the reality: this flight doesn’t have to cost you $500 or more each way. I’ve done it for under $150 roundtrip during sales, and I regularly find tickets in the $250-350 roundtrip range if I’m even somewhat flexible with dates.

The key is planning ahead when you can, but also staying alert for deals when you can’t. I keep a running list of approximate dates I might need to fly this route, and when I see a great price pop up, I seriously consider booking it even if the trip isn’t 100% confirmed yet. Most airlines let you cancel within 24 hours for a full refund, which gives you a day to figure out if you can make it work.

If you’re traveling with someone else, sometimes it’s worth checking if you can save money by booking your tickets separately instead of together. The airline pricing system is bizarre, and sometimes adding a second passenger to your search increases the per-person price because it shows you the price of the most expensive ticket category that has two seats available.

Also, don’t sleep on Southwest. I didn’t even mention them earlier because they don’t fly into JFK or LaGuardia—they use Newark and Long Island MacArthur—but their two-free-bags policy can save you $60-120 per person if you’re checking luggage. Sometimes the total cost ends up being cheaper even if the base fare is slightly higher.

Your credit card might offer better deals than you realize. I’ve got a Chase Sapphire card that lets me transfer points to airline partners, and I’ve used it to book this route a few times when paid tickets were expensive. The points-to-value ratio on domestic flights isn’t always amazing, but it beats paying cash during peak times.

Look, I know this was kind of a long deep-dive into what’s really just a regular domestic flight route. But after doing this trip dozens of times, I’ve figured out what works and what’s just a waste of money or stress. The LA to New York flight is one of the most traveled routes in the country, which means there’s tons of competition and plenty of opportunities to score deals if you know what you’re looking for.

Whether you’re visiting for the first time or you’re becoming a regular like me, you can definitely make this trip work without draining your bank account. Just stay flexible when you can, book smart, and remember that sometimes paying a little extra for a better flight time or airline is totally worth it for your sanity. Safe travels, and if you see someone aggressively typing on their laptop in a JetBlue window seat, there’s a decent chance it’s me working on another blog post about cheap flights.

---

Looking for direct flights from Los Angeles to New York? Get insider tips on booking cheap LAX to JFK flights under 6 hours. Discover budget-friendly travel hacks.

---