So here’s a confession—I spent way too long taking the train between New York and DC before I figured out that flying could actually be cheaper. I know, I know. The train is convenient, you avoid airport security, and there’s something kind of romantic about the Amtrak ride down the Northeast Corridor. But when I’m paying $150+ for a three-hour train ride and I can fly for $60? The romance wears off pretty quick.

The NYC to DC flight situation is honestly fascinating because it’s such a short distance—about 200 miles—that airlines treat it almost like a bus route. Multiple flights every hour, tiny planes sometimes, and prices that swing wildly depending on when you book and which airport you use. I’ve paid as little as $49 one-way and as much as $280 (that was a last-minute mistake I’m still annoyed about).

After making this trip probably twenty times over the past few years—visiting friends, checking out museums, attending a couple of weddings—I’ve gotten pretty good at gaming the system. Let me share what actually works, because this route has some quirks that are different from your typical flight.

The Airport Math That Changes Everything

New York has three major airports, DC has three airports, and choosing the wrong combination can cost you an extra hundred bucks without you even realizing it. I learned this the expensive way, naturally.

LaGuardia to Reagan is the premium route. It’s close-in on both ends, the flights are convenient, and you’ll pay for that convenience. I’ve rarely found this combo for under $150 roundtrip, and during busy times it can hit $300+. The flights are often on small regional jets, which means less legroom and overhead bin space, but at least you’re in and out quickly.

Newark to Dulles is where I’ve found some of my best deals, weirdly enough. United dominates this route, and I’ve gotten roundtrip tickets for under $100 several times. The downside is that both airports are further from downtown, so you’re adding commute time and cost on both ends. From Newark, you’re looking at NJ Transit or an expensive Uber into Manhattan. From Dulles, it’s either the Silver Line Metro (which takes forever) or a $60+ Uber into central DC.

But here’s my secret weapon: JFK to BWI. Southwest runs this route pretty regularly, and I’ve scored some absolutely ridiculous deals—$58 roundtrip back in October, $73 roundtrip in February. BWI is in Baltimore, about 45 minutes from downtown DC by MARC train, but if you’re staying near Union Station or anywhere along that line, it’s honestly not that bad. And JFK, while not the closest to Manhattan, has good transit connections via the AirTrain and subway.

I did the math once comparing a $160 LaGuardia to Reagan flight versus a $70 JFK to BWI flight. Even accounting for the extra transportation costs—AirTrain, subway, MARC train on the DC end—I was still saving about $50. Plus, Southwest lets you check two bags free, which matters if you’re staying a while.

The Train vs. Plane Calculation Nobody Talks About

Okay, so Amtrak costs between $100-300 depending on how far out you book and what time you travel. The Acela is faster but more expensive. Regular Northeast Regional trains are cheaper but take about three hours. Flying takes maybe an hour in the air, but then you’ve got to factor in getting to the airport early, security, possible delays, and getting from the destination airport into the city.

I’ve done both probably fifty times at this point, and here’s my actual takeaway: if you can get a flight for under $100 roundtrip and you’re not checking bags, flying wins on both time and money. If flights are over $150 and the train is around $100, I usually just take the train because the hassle factor isn’t worth the marginal savings.

There was this one time I booked a 6 AM flight out of Newark thinking I’d save money with the early departure. Had to leave my friend’s apartment in Brooklyn at 3:30 AM to make it to Newark by 5 AM for a 6 AM departure. Got maybe two hours of sleep. Saved $40 compared to the 9 AM flight. Was it worth it? Absolutely not. I was useless the entire first day in DC, drank about four coffees, and still felt like a zombie. Sometimes the cheaper option costs you in other ways.

How I Use Credit Card Points on This Route

The NYC to DC route is actually perfect for credit card points because the distances are so short that the point requirements are usually low. Delta, United, and JetBlue all fly this route heavily, and if you’ve got transferable points (Chase, Amex, Citi), you can usually find award availability pretty easily.

I’ve got the Chase Sapphire Preferred, and I transfer points to United for this route pretty regularly. A one-way award ticket is typically 6,000-7,500 United miles, which is pretty reasonable. I took a last-minute trip to DC in March using points—would’ve been $240 for a same-day booking, but I paid 7,500 points plus $5.60 in fees. Felt like highway robbery in the best possible way.

JetBlue’s TrueBlue program is also solid for this route if you fly out of JFK. Their points are usually valued around 1.3 cents each, and I’ve booked JFK to DCA flights for 3,500-5,000 points one-way. If you’ve got the JetBlue Plus card, you’re earning 6 points per dollar on JetBlue purchases, so the earning potential adds up fast if you fly them regularly.

The trick with points on short routes like this is that you’re often getting outsized value. Paying $5.60 in taxes for a flight that would’ve cost $120 means you’re getting nearly 2 cents per point in value, which is way better than most redemptions. I always check both cash and point prices before booking now.

Budget Airlines Are Actually Good on This Route

I used to avoid Spirit and Frontier pretty religiously, but for a 40-minute flight? They’re honestly fine. I flew Spirit from LaGuardia to Baltimore for $39 each way last summer, and the entire flight was so short that I barely had time to care about the cramped seats or lack of free snacks.

The key with budget airlines on short routes is understanding their fee structure and avoiding the traps. They charge for carry-ons, but a personal item (backpack, small tote bag) is always free. So I’ll pack light—just a backpack with a change of clothes, my laptop, and toiletries—and skip the carry-on fee entirely. Boom, just saved $35 each way.

For longer trips where I need more stuff, I actually check the bag. Sounds counterintuitive, but Spirit charges $30-45 for a carry-on and only $25-35 for a checked bag if you pay online during booking. So checking a bag is sometimes cheaper than carrying it on, which is wild.

I’ll be real though—budget airlines can be unreliable. I got burned once when a Frontier flight from Newark to DCA was delayed by four hours due to “mechanical issues.” No meal vouchers, no real communication, just sitting at the gate slowly losing my mind. Ended up missing dinner plans with friends. Would I have paid an extra $60 for a more reliable airline knowing that would happen? Yeah, probably. But most of the time, budget airlines work fine for this short hop.

When to Book for the Best Prices

The NYC to DC route is weird because it’s so heavily traveled by business people that pricing patterns don’t always follow typical leisure travel logic. I’ve tracked prices pretty obsessively—yes, I have a spreadsheet, don’t judge me—and here’s what I’ve noticed.

The absolute cheapest fares tend to pop up about 3-6 weeks out. Less than two weeks out and you’re usually paying a premium. More than 10 weeks out and prices haven’t really dropped to their lowest yet. There are exceptions obviously, but that 3-6 week window has been reliable for me.

Midweek flights are consistently cheaper. Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday are your friends. Monday mornings and Friday evenings are when business travelers are flying, so those flights cost more. I’ve seen Tuesday afternoon flights for $60 when Friday evening flights on the same route were $220. Just absurd.

Early morning flights are often cheaper too, but there’s a limit to how early I’m willing to go. The 6 AM departures are usually pretty affordable, but waking up at 4 AM to catch a flight from NYC? I’ll pass unless the savings are dramatic. I’ve found that 8-10 AM flights often hit a sweet spot of reasonable prices without the brutal wake-up time.

One surprise I discovered: flights right around lunch time (11 AM – 1 PM) are often cheaper than either morning or evening options. I think it’s because business travelers want to either fly first thing in the morning or later in the afternoon, so midday flights have less demand. I’ve booked several 11:30 AM or noon flights that were $20-40 cheaper than the 9 AM options.

Setting Up Alerts That Actually Work

Google Flights alerts have saved me so much money on this route. I set up an alert for NYC to DC (using the “any” option for airports on both ends) with flexible dates, and I get notifications whenever there’s a significant price drop.

The alerts caught a crazy Delta sale last November—JFK to DCA for $49 each way. I wasn’t even planning a trip to DC, but for that price I figured I’d make one up. Called my college roommate who lives in Arlington, told her I’d be in town that weekend, and booked the flight. We had an impromptu reunion that ended up being one of my favorite trips of the year.

The trick is actually being flexible. If you need to fly specific dates for work or an event, price alerts won’t help much. But for casual visits or exploration trips where your dates are loose, those alerts are gold. I’d say about 40% of my NYC to DC trips have been sparked by a price alert showing me a deal I couldn’t resist.

I also follow a couple of deal accounts on Twitter (or X, whatever we’re calling it now) that specialize in Northeast flights. Going (formerly Scott’s Cheap Flights) occasionally highlights deals on this route, though it’s usually more focused on international travel. Secret Flying and The Flight Deal have both posted NYC to DC mistake fares that I’ve jumped on.

The Positioning Flight Hack That Sounds Crazy But Works

Sometimes—and I know this sounds wild—the cheapest way to get from NYC to DC isn’t a direct flight. I’ve found times when flying NYC to Philadelphia to DC was like $70 cheaper than going direct. The routing adds an hour or two to your total travel time, but if you’ve got nowhere to be and you’re trying to maximize your budget, it can work.

I did this once almost by accident. I found an amazing deal on a flight from Newark to Philly ($35), and I knew I could get a cheap Southwest flight from Philly to Baltimore for around $40. Total cost: $75 for what would’ve been a $180 direct flight. Was it efficient? No. Did I feel a little ridiculous making a connection for a route that’s only 200 miles? Absolutely. But I saved a hundred bucks, so who’s really winning here?

The catch is that you need to book these as separate tickets, which means if something goes wrong with your first flight and you miss your connection, you’re on your own. The airlines won’t help you because they don’t see it as a connection—they see it as two unrelated trips. So there’s definitely risk involved. I only do this when I’ve got time flexibility and the savings are really significant.

Last-Minute Flights When You’re Desperate

Okay, so you need to get from NYC to DC tomorrow and you haven’t booked anything yet. First of all, take a deep breath. Second, yes, it’s going to be more expensive than if you’d booked ahead, but it’s not hopeless.

I’ve had to do last-minute bookings maybe five times on this route—usually for work stuff that came up suddenly or family emergencies. The prices are always painful, but I’ve learned some ways to minimize the damage.

Check Southwest first. Their pricing structure is a bit different from other airlines, and sometimes their last-minute fares are actually reasonable compared to the highway robbery you’ll find on other carriers. I booked a same-day Southwest flight from Newark to Baltimore once for $180, which hurt, but Delta and United were both over $300 for the same day.

Look at odd times. That 6 AM flight or the 9 PM red-eye might be cheaper than midday options simply because fewer people want them. I took a 10 PM flight from JFK to DCA once that was $120 cheaper than the 6 PM departure. Yeah, I got into DC at midnight and felt pretty rough the next morning, but I saved enough money to buy dinner and drinks the next night.

Consider the train if flights are truly outrageous. I’ve had situations where last-minute Amtrak tickets were actually comparable to last-minute flights when you factored in the total door-to-door time and hassle. The train at least lets you work or relax without dealing with airports.

When It Makes Sense to Just Pay More

Look, I’m obsessed with finding cheap flights, but I’m not going to tell you that the cheapest option is always the right call. There’ve been times when I’ve intentionally paid more for convenience or peace of mind.

If you’re flying for something important—a job interview, a crucial client meeting, a wedding—spending an extra $50-80 for a direct flight on a reliable airline with good rebooking options might be worth it. I learned this after booking a super cheap Spirit flight for what turned out to be a really important work meeting. The flight got delayed, I showed up late and stressed, and I probably made a terrible impression. The $40 I saved was not worth the professional consequences.

Also, if you’re checking bags, sometimes the “expensive” airline ends up being comparable to the budget carrier once you add in baggage fees. Southwest lets you check two bags free, which is huge if you’re traveling with equipment or staying for a while. Delta and United charge but at least their first checked bag is included if you have their credit card.

And sometimes you’re just tired and don’t want to deal with multiple connections or budget airline chaos. That’s valid. Your mental energy and time have value too. I’ve definitely paid an extra $60 for a nonstop flight at a convenient time because I just didn’t have it in me to optimize further that particular week.

Making It All Come Together

The NYC to DC route is genuinely one of the most hackable flights in the country because it’s so competitive and so frequent. Multiple airlines, multiple airports, literally dozens of flights per day. If you’re willing to be flexible about timing and airports, you can consistently find deals under $100 roundtrip.

My personal strategy is pretty straightforward: I set up Google Flights alerts, I check all the airport combinations, I consider budget airlines for short trips, and I use credit card points when prices are high. Some trips I get lucky and find amazing deals. Other trips I just book something reasonable and move on with my life.

But over the past three years of making this trip regularly, I’d estimate I’ve saved at least $1,500 compared to what I would’ve paid if I just booked whatever came up first. That’s real money that I’ve been able to put toward other trips, experiences, or just not worrying about my bank account as much.

The key is treating flight search as a game rather than a chore. Set up your alerts, check a few different options, and don’t stress too much if you don’t find the absolute rock-bottom price. Even saving $30-50 per trip adds up fast when you’re traveling regularly.

---