I’m going to tell you about the time I paid $240 for a hotel room in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter just to be walking distance from Petco Park. This was back in 2019, and I was visiting for a Padres game against the Dodgers. I figured, hey, I’ll splurge this once—how bad could it be?

Turns out, pretty bad for my wallet. The hotel was nice enough, sure, but I basically paid a premium to stumble back to my room after the game instead of taking a 10-minute rideshare. When I did the math later (because I’m that person who obsessively tracks travel expenses), I realized I could’ve stayed three nights somewhere else for the same price.

Since then, I’ve been back to San Diego for baseball games, concerts at Petco Park, and just general downtown exploring probably eight or nine times. And I’ve gotten way smarter about finding cheap hotels near Petco Park San Diego without sacrificing comfort or safety. The trick is knowing where to look and being okay with a little bit of flexibility.

The Downtown Fringe Strategy That Actually Works

Here’s something most visitors don’t realize: downtown San Diego isn’t that big. Like, you can walk from one end to the other in maybe 30 minutes. So when people obsess over staying right in the Gaslamp Quarter or East Village (the neighborhoods immediately around Petco Park), they’re paying a massive premium for maybe 10 blocks of difference.

My favorite area to target is what I call the “downtown fringe”—basically the edges of downtown near Little Italy, Cortez Hill, and the area along Harbor Drive. I stayed at a hotel on Ash Street once, right on the border between downtown and Little Italy, and paid $89 a night. The walk to Petco Park took me about 15 minutes, which honestly felt good after sitting through a three-hour baseball game.

The neighborhood around Little Italy especially has some solid mid-range options that people skip over because they’re not technically “downtown downtown.” But you’re still close enough to walk to Petco Park, and honestly, Little Italy is way more fun to hang out in than the Gaslamp anyway. Better restaurants, less touristy, and it has this cool local vibe that the Gaslamp just doesn’t have anymore.

I found a Best Western up there during my 2022 trip for $95 a night, and the location was perfect. After the game, I walked up India Street, grabbed some late-night pizza at this spot called Landini’s, and felt like I was actually experiencing San Diego rather than just doing the tourist circuit.

Old Town: The Budget Traveler’s Secret Weapon (Again)

Okay, I know I mentioned Old Town in my SeaWorld article, but hear me out—it works just as well for Petco Park visits. The San Diego Trolley Blue Line runs directly from Old Town to the Gaslamp Quarter station, which is literally right next to Petco Park. The ride takes about 15 minutes, costs like $2.50, and runs pretty frequently, especially on game days.

I’ve stayed in Old Town twice specifically for Padres games, and both times I found hotel rooms under $85 a night. That’s compared to the $150-250 you’d pay to stay in the Gaslamp or East Village. Even factoring in trolley fare both ways, you’re saving a ton of money.

The thing about Old Town is that it’s not going to feel like a big city downtown experience. It’s more residential, historical, and honestly kind of sleepy after dark. But if you’re primarily coming to San Diego for an event at Petco Park and want to save money, it’s a totally viable option. Plus, there’s free parking at most Old Town hotels, which is huge because parking in downtown San Diego is absolutely painful and expensive.

One time I stayed at a Hampton Inn in Old Town, and the front desk person told me that tons of their guests were actually in town for Padres games. They even had information about the trolley schedule at the front desk. So it’s definitely a known strategy among budget-conscious travelers.

The Mission Valley Hack Nobody Talks About

This one’s a bit outside the box, but Mission Valley has become one of my go-to areas for cheap hotels near Petco Park San Diego. It’s about 15-20 minutes from downtown by car, and it’s basically this big commercial area with shopping centers, chain restaurants, and—most importantly—a bunch of reasonably priced hotels.

I stayed at a hotel in Mission Valley during Comic-Con once (yeah, I know, not exactly a Petco Park event, but same downtown location). The hotel was $78 a night during one of the busiest weekends of the year in San Diego. I took rideshares to and from downtown, which cost about $12-15 each way, but even with that expense, I was still way under what I would’ve paid to stay downtown.

The Mission Valley trolley stops also connect directly to the Gaslamp Quarter, so you’ve got that public transit option too if you don’t want to rely on rideshares. The trolley ride is maybe 20 minutes, and it’s kind of nice actually—you get to see different neighborhoods and you don’t have to worry about parking or traffic.

The main downside is that Mission Valley itself is pretty boring. It’s all hotels, shopping centers, and chain restaurants. There’s not much to do within walking distance of your hotel. But if you’re spending your time downtown at Petco Park or exploring the Gaslamp Quarter anyway, it doesn’t really matter.

Bankers Hill and Hillcrest: The Underrated Neighborhoods

I discovered Bankers Hill kind of by accident during my 2023 trip. I was searching for hotels and this little boutique spot in Bankers Hill popped up for $105 a night. I didn’t know much about the area, but the reviews were good and the price was right, so I booked it.

Turns out, Bankers Hill is this charming residential neighborhood just north of downtown. It’s on a hill (shocker, I know), so you get these cool views of the bay and downtown skyline. More importantly, it’s only about a 15-20 minute walk to Petco Park, mostly downhill on the way there, which is nice.

The neighborhood has a bunch of local coffee shops, some good restaurants, and it feels way more like a real San Diego neighborhood than the tourist-heavy Gaslamp area. I walked to Petco Park for a concert, and the route took me through parts of Little Italy and past Waterfront Park. It was actually a pretty nice evening stroll.

Hillcrest, which is right next to Bankers Hill, also has some decent hotel options. It’s a bit farther from Petco Park—maybe 25-30 minutes on foot—but you can easily catch a rideshare or even take a Bird scooter if you’re into that. I’ve seen hotel rates in Hillcrest as low as $79 a night, and it’s a super cool neighborhood with tons of restaurants, bars, and local shops.

The only thing to consider is that both neighborhoods are on hills, so if you’re walking back to your hotel after a game or concert, you’re going to be walking uphill. It’s not terrible, but if you’ve got mobility issues or you’re just exhausted, you might want to budget for a rideshare back.

National City and Chula Vista: Going Farther South

Alright, this is where some people might think I’m crazy, but hear me out. National City and Chula Vista are south of downtown San Diego, and they have some genuinely cheap hotel options. I’m talking $60-75 a night even during peak season.

I stayed in National City once when I was doing a longer San Diego trip and needed to keep my accommodation costs low. The hotel was nothing fancy—pretty standard Motel 6 situation—but it was clean, safe, and the staff was friendly. Getting to Petco Park took about 20 minutes by car, maybe 25 with traffic.

The thing about this area is that it’s definitely more working-class and industrial. You’re not going to have that vacation vibe or walkable neighborhoods with cute cafes. But if you’re primarily focused on attending an event at Petco Park and you want to maximize your budget for other things—like good food downtown or maybe taking a day trip to La Jolla—staying farther south can make a lot of sense.

I will say that I probably wouldn’t recommend this area if you’re not comfortable with urban environments or if you’re traveling solo and feeling nervous about safety. It’s totally fine and I never felt unsafe, but it’s definitely a different vibe than staying in downtown or the nicer neighborhoods.

The Rideshare Math for Petco Park Hotels

Let me break down the actual numbers because I’m a spreadsheet nerd and I’ve literally calculated this multiple times. Say you find a hotel in the Gaslamp Quarter for $200 a night. That’s convenient, for sure—you can walk to Petco Park in five minutes.

Now say you find a hotel in Mission Valley or Old Town for $80 a night. Even if you take a rideshare both ways to Petco Park, that’s maybe $25-30 total per day. So your daily cost is $110 versus $200. You’re saving $90 a day, which over a three-night trip is $270. That’s serious money.

The only time this math doesn’t work as well is if you’re planning to go back and forth to your hotel multiple times a day, or if you’re staying for just one night and the rideshare costs eat up more of your savings. But for most normal trips where you’re going to Petco Park for a game or event and then maybe exploring downtown for a bit, staying farther out is way more economical.

I also use the trolley whenever possible because $2.50 beats $15 for an Uber, and honestly, I kind of enjoy the trolley experience. It feels more like you’re part of the city rather than just passing through in the back of someone’s car.

What I Learned About Booking Timing

This probably deserves its own article, but booking timing is huge for finding cheap hotels near Petco Park San Diego. I made the mistake of booking a hotel three days before a Padres playoff game once, and even the budget options were charging premium rates.

My best experiences have come from booking at least 2-3 weeks in advance, or even earlier if you’re coming during a major event like Comic-Con or a big concert series. Hotels know when demand is high, and they adjust their prices accordingly.

I also check prices on Tuesday or Wednesday mornings, because I read somewhere that hotels often update their rates midweek. I don’t know if that’s actually true or just travel blog folklore, but I’ve definitely found good deals on Wednesday mornings.

And here’s a weird tip: sometimes calling the hotel directly gets you a better rate than booking online. I called a Holiday Inn Express near downtown once just to ask about their rates, and they offered me a AAA discount that wasn’t showing up on their website. It saved me like $18 a night, which adds up over several days.

The Neighborhoods I Actually Avoid

In the interest of being totally honest, there are some areas I generally skip when looking for budget hotels near Petco Park. The hotels right along the I-5 near the airport can be tempting because they’re sometimes cheap, but the noise from planes and highway traffic is pretty intense. I stayed at one once and barely slept because of the constant aircraft noise.

I also tend to avoid the hotels on the very southern edge of downtown along Harbor Drive near the convention center, even though they’re close to Petco Park. Not because they’re bad, but because they tend to be either really expensive convention hotels or sketchy budget options without much in between.

And while Coronado is beautiful and has some hotels that occasionally run deals, it’s generally too pricey for budget travel, plus you’re crossing a bridge to get to downtown which adds time and potentially toll costs.

My Current Strategy for Petco Park Trips

These days, here’s what I do: I start by checking rates in Little Italy, Old Town, and Mission Valley. Those are my three go-to areas for the best combination of price, safety, and convenience. I’m willing to pay up to about $100 a night for a decent hotel in one of those areas.

Then I look at the trolley schedule to make sure public transit is viable, or I calculate potential rideshare costs if I’m going to need those. I read recent reviews on Google and TripAdvisor to make sure the place is actually clean and well-maintained—because cheap is only worth it if you’re not dealing with bedbugs or sketchy situations.

I also check if there are any hotel packages that include things like parking passes or credits for nearby restaurants. Sometimes those deals actually save money even if the nightly rate looks a bit higher.

And honestly, I’ve stopped feeling bad about staying outside the immediate Gaslamp Quarter area. Yeah, it’s convenient to be right there, but the Gaslamp has gotten so touristy and overpriced that I actually prefer staying in neighborhoods that feel more authentic anyway.

The Real Bottom Line

Finding cheap hotels near Petco Park San Diego isn’t about suffering through terrible accommodations or spending hours commuting. It’s about being strategic with your location, using public transit or rideshares when it makes sense, and not falling for the idea that you need to stay right in the Gaslamp Quarter to have a good San Diego experience.

Little Italy, Old Town, Mission Valley, and even Bankers Hill all offer solid budget-friendly options that are still close enough to Petco Park to be convenient. You might walk an extra 10 minutes or take a quick trolley ride, but you’ll save enough money to actually enjoy your time in San Diego instead of stressing about your hotel bill.

My advice? Book early, be flexible with location, and remember that a hotel is basically just a place to sleep when you’re spending your time at Petco Park or exploring downtown anyway. Save your money for the good stuff—maybe those craft beers at the ballpark or an amazing brunch in Little Italy the next morning.

Trust me, your wallet will thank you, and you’ll still have just as good of a time as the people who dropped $250 a night to stay in the Gaslamp.

---